Page 3 of 3
The last time I wrote about Azure Machine Learning, the old drag-and-drop designer had been deprecated, and there was a new emphasis on Python programming and Azure (Jupyter) Notebooks, essentially raising the bar on skills. The designer has now been revamped, and both the designer and AutoML given equal emphasis to Notebooks. Another improvement is the addition of R support and RStudio Server integration.
Microsoft’s own high-level summary of Azure ML emphasizes “productivity for all skill levels,” end-to-end MLOps, state-of-the-art responsible ML, and “best-in-class support for open-source frameworks and languages including MLflow, Kubeflow, ONNX, PyTorch, TensorFlow, Python, and R.” As key service capabilities, Microsoft mentions collaborative notebooks, automated machine learning, drag and drop machine learning, data labeling, MLOps, autoscaling compute, RStudio integration, deep integration with other Azure services, reinforcement learning, responsible ML, enterprise-grade security, and cost management.
Rather than create a notebook from scratch for the purposes of this review, I started with a Microsoft sample notebook.
I chose one of the sample notebooks that demonstrate explainable machine learning. This is only one of the new capabilities of Azure Notebooks. Others include forecasting and reinforcement learning.
To actually run a sample notebook, you need to clone it into your own directory and add a compute resource instance.
This notebook creates an additional compute resource to run the model, a remote cluster of up to four nodes. Then it submits a script to the cluster, specifying dependencies of Pandas and Scikit-learn, and waits for the script to complete.
This run took 5 minutes 39 seconds. Much of that time was the five minutes spent waiting for the remote resource to spin up, which was annoying—but that’s the price you pay for creating compute resources on demand and releasing them when they are idle.
Finally, the notebook downloads the results from the remote cluster and lets you analyze them with the explanation dashboard. The What-if tool is comparable to Google’s, but not limited to TensorFlow models. This particular example builds a Scikit-learn model.
Azure Machine Learning notebooks currently have pre-release support for R and RStudio. I was able to create an RStudio environment from the Compute tab (see the first screenshot below) and clone the sample vignettes by following the instructions in the tutorial. I ran into trouble at the “load your workspace” stage, but fixed it by reinstalling the Azure Machine Learning SDK for R from GitHub. Unfortunately, I ran into more bugs at the
create_estimator() call that I couldn’t fix, and gave up. (See the second screenshot below.) Oh, well: It was advertised as pre-release, and it was.
Automated ML in Azure is not as new as it looks. As far as I can tell, it’s a nice user interface around the AutoMLConfig method that has been available in Azure Notebooks since at least early 2019. What is new under the covers? Forecasts, explanations, and featurization (automatic feature engineering).
I’ll note that Azure Automated ML currently only works on tabular or file data sets, just like Google AutoML Tables. DataRobot (see my review) is more flexible, and does AutoML using a mix of training data types, including images. While an Azure AutoML task of type image-instance-segmentation was added to the code in December 2020, I haven’t yet found it in the user interface or tutorials.
For fun, you can compare the Bike share AutoML forecasting tutorial with the notebook version of the same analysis. As a crusty old Python programmer, I prefer the notebook, but you may find the graphical interface easier for new AutoML projects.
The Azure Machine Learning Designer is a no-code/low-code graphical interface for creating pipelines. While it resembles the old Azure Machine Learning Studio interface, it uses the much more robust infrastructure now available in Azure Machine Learning, including clusters of VM-based nodes, which may have GPUs or FGPAs, as compute targets. The Designer’s graphical approach to pipeline creation is similar to KNIME, although KNIME has many more modules.
With Azure Machine Learning datasets, you can keep a single copy of data in your storage referenced by datasets and access data during model training without worrying about connection strings or data paths.
Your machine learning experiments and the runs within each experiment are listed in the Experiments tab.
Pipelines show the Designer runs you’ve completed in the Pipeline runs tab, and diagrams you haven’t run in the Pipeline drafts tab. Azure Machine Learning pipelines can be published to get a REST endpoint that can be invoked from an external client. Clicking into a Pipeline brings up the diagram as an experiment run.
Completed models are listed in the Models tab whether or not they have been deployed. You can deploy models to create web service endpoints, listed in the Endpoints tab.
You can manage your compute instances, compute clusters, inference clusters, and attached compute resources in the Compute tab. That’s a good place to check for running instances that you might want to kill before they accrue long-term charges.
Any dataset you register appears in the Datastores tab. The underlying storage may be Azure Blob storage or an Azure file share.
Azure Machine Learning data labeling gives you a central place to create, manage, and monitor labeling projects. Data labeling currently supports image classification, either multi-label or multi-class, and object identification with bounded boxes.
Data labeling tracks progress and maintains the queue of incomplete labeling tasks. This is a manual process with two optional phases of machine learning assistance: clustering and pre-labeling. The latter uses transfer learning, and may be available after only a few hundred images have been manually labeled if your categories are similar to the pre-trained model.
The Open Neural Network Exchange (ONNX) can help optimize the inference of your trained machine learning model. Models from many frameworks, including TensorFlow, PyTorch, Scihit-learn, Keras, Chainer, MXNet, Matlab, and Spark MLlib, can be exported or converted to the standard ONNX format.
Azure Databricks provides hosted, optimized Apache Spark clusters running on Azure. Spark is a big data analytics service that includes its own machine learning libraries. Azure Databricks integrates with Azure Machine Learning, Azure Data Factory, Azure Data Lake Storage, and Azure Synapse Analytics.
Azure Cognitive Search
Azure Cognitive Search is a cloud search service with built-in AI capabilities that enrich all types of information, to identify and explore relevant content at scale. Formerly known as Azure Search, it uses the same integrated Microsoft natural language stack that Bing and Office have used for more than a decade, and AI services across vision, language, and speech. In other words, Microsoft Search uses Cognitive Search technology to offer software as a service for enterprise search within Microsoft products.
Azure Bot Service
Using bots is one way to automate or partially automate customer service and help desks. The Azure Bot Service and the Microsoft Bot Framework SDK help you to create bots and integrate them with Azure Cognitive Services. Once created, you can apply bots to channels including your website or apps, Microsoft Teams, Skype, Slack, Cortana, and Facebook Messenger.
Bots can be as sophisticated as you want to make them. You can start simple with informational bots, essentially front ends to your FAQ documents. Then you can add capabilities, for example by using the Azure Text Analytics and Language Understanding services to determine customer intent so that the bot can do customer escalations and help desk triage.
AI and machine learning on Azure
Overall, the Azure AI and Machine Learning platform—including the Azure Cognitive Services, Azure Machine Learning, the ONNX Runtime, Azure Databricks, Azure Cognitive Search, and Azure Bot Service—offers a wide range of cognitive services and a solid platform for machine learning that supports automatic machine learning, no-code/low-code machine learning, and Python-based notebooks. All of the services are very solid, and almost all services have a free tier for development and test. The only bug I found was in an experimental RStudio notebook, and that appeared to be a simple library version mismatch. (Yes, I reported the bug.)
I was impressed by the ability of Azure custom cognitive services to do transfer learning with single-digit numbers of samples, for example Custom Vision and Form Recognizer. I was also impressed by the progress the Azure Responsible AI offerings have made, although I suspect that there’s more work to be done in that area.
How does Azure AI compare to Google Cloud AI and Amazon’s AI and machine learning offerings? The quality and scope are similar; you can’t really go wrong with any of them. While I haven’t yet absorbed all of the improvements that AWS announced at re:Invent in December 2020, I can say that one differentiator between Azure and Google cognitive services is that Azure allows you to run cognitive service containers on premises, while Google currently lacks on-prem options.
Note: In general, production services have a 99.9% SLA.
Anomaly detection: 20K free transactions/month (10 calls/second dev/test); $0.314/1K transactions/month (80 calls/second production).
Content Moderator: 5K free transactions/month (1 transaction/second dev/test); $1/1K transactions/month (10 transactions/second production) + volume discounts over 1M transactions/month.
Metrics Advisor: No charge during preview.
Personalizer: 50K free transactions/month (10 GB storage); $1/1K transactions/month + volume discounts over 1M transactions/month.
Immersive Reader: No charge during preview.
Language Understanding: 10K free transactions/month; (5 TPS dev/test); $1.50/1K transactions/month text, $5.50/1K transactions/month speech (50 TPS production).
QnA Maker: 3 managed documents free each month (dev/test); $10 for unlimited managed documents. QnA also requires an App Service (free to $0.285/hour) and a Cognitive Search service (free to $7.667/hour).
Text Analytics: 5K free transactions/month; standard $1/1K text records with volume discounts; tiers from $74.71/month for 25K transactions to $5K/month for 10M transactions.
Translator: 2M chars free/month; $10 per million chars of standard translation, $40 per million chars of custom translation; standard translation tiers from $2K/month for 250M chars to $45K/month for 10B chars, custom translation tiers from $2K/month for 62.5M chars to $45K/month for 2.5B chars.
Speech to Text: 5 audio hours free per month, 1 concurrent request; $1 per audio hour, 20 concurrent requests.
Text to Speech: 5 million characters free per month standard, 0.5 million characters free per month neural; $4 per 1M characters standard, $16 per 1M characters neural, $100 per 1M characters neural long audio.
Speech Translation: 5 audio hours free per month; $2.50 per audio hour.
Computer Vision: 5K transactions free per month (20/minute); $1 to $1.50 per 1K transactions (10 TPS) with volume discounts.
Custom Vision: 1 hour training, 5K training images, and 10K predictions free/month (2 TPS); $20/compute hour training, $2 per 1K transactions, $0.70 per 1K images storage (10 TPS).
Face: 30K free transactions/month (20 TPM); $1 per 1K transactions with volume discounts (10 TPS).
Form Recognizer: 500 pages free per month; $10 to $50 per 1K pages depending on form type.
Video Indexer: 10 hours of free indexing to website users and 40 hours of free indexing to API users; $0.15/minute for video analysis, $0.04/minute for audio analysis.
Azure Machine Learning: $0.016 to $26.688/hour depending on number of CPUs, GPUs, and FPGAs, and amount of RAM; storage costs additional. VM costs only; No extra charge for machine learning service.
Azure Databricks: Combination of VM and service costs. See pricing details.
Azure Cognitive Search: Free to $3.839/hour, plus $1/1K images with volume discounts for document image extraction.
Azure Bot Service: Standard channels free; Premium channels free for 10K messages/month, S1 $0.50/1K messages.
Microsoft Azure cloud. A number of Azure Cognitive Services are available as Docker containers to be deployed on-premises.
At a Glance
Microsoft Azure AI and Machine Learning
Microsoft Azure AI and Machine Learning offers a wide range of cognitive services and a solid platform for machine learning that supports automated machine learning, no-code/low-code machine learning, and Python-based notebooks. All of the services are very solid.
- Most services have a free tier for development and test.
- Transfer-learning services such as Custom Vision and Form Recognizer can learn from a small number of samples (in the single digits).
- A subset of cognitive services is available to run in containers on-premises.
- Azure has made good progress on Responsible AI.
- Azure currently lacks natural language generation services.
- Machine Learning
- Deep Learning
- Artificial Intelligence
- Cloud Computing
- Enterprise Review
Martin Heller is a contributing editor and reviewer for InfoWorld. Formerly a web and Windows programming consultant, he developed databases, software, and websites from 1986 to 2010. More recently, he has served as VP of technology and education at Alpha Software and chairman and CEO at Tubifi.
Copyright © 2021 IDG Communications, Inc.
Page 3 of 3
How to choose a low-code development platform